Looking for the best pizza in Pennsylvania? This directory brings together more than a decade of NEPA Pizza Review visits, ratings, and real pizza experiences from pizzerias across the Keystone State. Since 2012, I’ve reviewed everything from Old Forge trays and New York-style slices to Sicilian squares, pan pizza, bar pies, grandma pizza, tomato pie, and hidden-gem neighborhood shops.
To make this list as helpful as possible, I’ve organized the reviews by county so you can quickly find pizza near you, plan a pizza road trip, or compare local favorites. I’ve also removed reviews for pizzerias that have permanently closed, so you can spend less time clicking dead ends and more time finding your next great slice. Scroll through the county list below, click any pizzeria name to read the full review, and see which places are worth adding to your own pizza bucket list.
Browse NEPA Pizza Review’s Pennsylvania pizza reviews by county. Each linked listing opens the full review.
Berks County
Bucks County
Carbon County
Centre County
Columbia County
- Berwick Original Italian Pizza – Berwick
- Bob’s Subs and Pizza – Berwick
- Bricktown Pizza – Berwick
- Dalo’s Bakery – Berwick
- Kings Pizza – Berwick
- Mifflin Pizza – Mifflinville
- Scicchitano’s Pizzeria – Berwick
- Stuccio’s Pizzeria – Berwick
- Tuzzi’s Bakery – Berwick
- Unida Pizza – Bloomsburg
Dauphin County
- Amico’s Pizza – Harrisburg
- Jo Jo’s Pizza – Hummelstown
- Palermo’s – Hummelstown
- Piazza Sorrento – Hershey
- Roberto’s Pizza – Harrisburg
Lackawanna County
- 1905 Tavern – Scranton
- A Little Pizza Heaven – Scranton
- AJ’s Bar and Grill – Carbondale
- Aldo’s – Taylor
- Alfredo’s Cafe – Scranton
- Amberdonia Bakery – Dickson City
- Andy Gavin’s – Scranton
- Andy’s Pizza – Peckville
- Angie’s Pizza – Dickson City
- Anthony’s Restaurant – Old Forge
- Antonio’s Pizza – Scranton
- Arcaro and Genell’s – Old Forge
- Arcaro’s Pizza – Taylor
- Armenti’s Pizzeria – Olyphant
- Armetta’s Restaurant and Pizzeria – Clarks Summit
- Augustine’s Club 17 – Old Forge
- Baker Boyz Old Forge Pizza – Clarks Summit
- Bar Pazzo – Scranton
- Barletta’s Bar – Scranton
- Bartari – Scranton
- Basilico’s Pizzeria – Dickson City
- Benny’s – Peckville
- Bobo’s Pizza – Old Forge
- Brick Oven Pizzeria – Scranton
- Bull’s Head NY Pizza & Taqeria – Scranton
- Buona Pizza – Scranton
- Burrito Loco Cantina & Grill – Dickson City
- Cafe Classico – Scranton
- Cafe Rinaldi – Old Forge
- Calabria Pizza – Dunmore
- Cali’s Don Tomaso Peatza – Dunmore
- Callela’s Pizza – Scranton
- Camelot – Clarks Summit
- Cara Mia’s – Dunmore
- Carmella’s – Dunmore
- Chinchilla Hose Co – Chinchilla
- Chuck E Cheese – Dickson City
- Colarosso’s Pizza – Dunmore
- Colarusso’s Cafe – Jessup
- Colarusso’s Clarks Summit – Clarks Summit
- Colarusso’s Coal Fired Pizza – Dickson City
- Cosmo’s Cheesesteaks – Scranton
- Cusumano – Old Forge
- D’Amore Pizza – Taylor
- DaVinci Pizza – Scranton
- DeeJay’s Pizza and Hoagies – Scranton
- Dino and Francesco’s – Moosic
- Dino and Francesco’s Pizza – Clarks Summit
- Diskin’s Saloon – Scranton
- Doma Importing – Dunmore
- Domino’s Pizza – Clarks Summit
- Duke’s Pizza – Dunmore
- Electric City Pizza – Scranton
- Ferri’s Pizza – Moscow
- Frank’s Place – Simpson
- Fratelli’s Pizza and Pasta House – Scranton
- G&M Warehouse – Scranton
- Gangi Pizza – Throop
- Gio’s Pizza Co – Clarks Summit
- Gold Crown Pizza – Dunmore
- Goodfellas Pizza – Scranton
- Grande Family Restaurant – Moosic
- Grande Pizza – Dunmore
- Granteed’s Pizza – Scranton
- Green Ridge News – Scranton
- Green Ridge Pizza – Scranton
- Happy Valley Sports Bar – Dickson City
- Jessup Pizza – Jessup
- Joey’s Pizza – Dunmore
- John’s of Arthur Ave – Milford
- Joyce’s Cafe – Scranton
- Katrina’s Pizza – Dickson City
- Kay’s Pizzeria – Daleville
- La Rocca Pizza & Pasta – Scranton
- LaPadrino’s Pizzeria – Archbald
- Laura’s Pizza and Hoagies – Montdale
- Legend’s Saloon – Dickson City
- Little Caesars Pizza – Scranton
- Lou’s Pizza – Olyphant
- Luigi’s Pizzeria – Olyphant
- Lupo Rosso Wood Fired Pizza – Scranton
- Mainline Pizza and Hoagie – Dickson City
- Mamma Mia Pizza – Scranton
- Maroni’s Pizza House – Scranton
- Mary Lou’s Pizza – Old Forge
- McGrath’s Pub and Eatery – Dalton
- Mendicino’s Pizzeria – Covington Twp
- Mutant Brewing – Scranton
- Nearra’s Pizza – Scranton
- Nicholas Pizza Shop – Scranton
- Nickie’s Fabulous Hoagies – Clarks Summit
- Nina’s – Dunmore
- Nina’s 5 Star Veggie Pizza – Scranton
- Nina’s Wing Bites and Pizza – South Abington Township
- Nonno’s Pizza – Moosic
- Novello’s Pizzeria – Scranton
- Olde Brook Inn – Spring Brook Township
- Original Pizza on Drinker – Scranton
- Pasquale’s Pizzeria – Eynon
- Pat’s Pizza and Hoagies – Carbondale
- Peanut Bar – Carbondale
- Pepper’s Pizza – Scranton
- Picciocchi’s Pasta – Scranton
- Pizza Avenue – Scranton
- Pizza by Pappas – Scranton
- Pizza Heaven – Luzerne
- Pizza Plus – Scranton
- Revello’s Pizza Cafe – Old Forge
- Roma Pizza – Dickson City
- Roosevelt Beer Garden – Dunmore
- Rosario’s Pizzeria – Clarks Summit
- Rosario’s Pizzeria Viewmont – Dickson City
- Roseanna’s Pizza – Scranton
- Royal Pizza – Carbondale
- Ruano’s Pizza & Pasta – Scranton
- Sacco’s Pizza – Scranton
- Salerno’s Cafe – Old Forge
- Samario’s Scranton – Scranton
- Schultzville Deli – Clarks Summit
- Sibio’s Restaurant – Dunmore
- Spin and Savory – Scranton
- State Street Grill – Clarks Summit
- Taylor Deli – Taylor
- That Guy With the Dough – Moosic
- The Dugout – Scranton
- The Stonehouse – Carbondale
- Tony’s Pizza – Peckville
- Two Brothers Pizza – Dunmore
- Union Craft House – Taylor
- Vidaro’s – Blakely
- Vince the Pizza Prince – Scranton
- Vincenzo’s Pizzeria Scott Twp – Scott Township
- Vincenzo’s Pizzeria Scranton – Scranton
- Wegmans – Dickson City
- Wicked Mushroom – Scranton
Lancaster County
- Ciro’s Italian Bistro – Lancaster
- Rosa Rosa Pizzeria – Lancaster
- Slugger’s Pizza – Lancaster
- Two Cousins – Paradise
- Venice Pizza and Pasta – Lancaster
Lehigh County
Luzerne County
- Adelina’s Pizzeria – Dallas
- Alta Pizzeria and Pasta House – Hazleton
- Angelo’s Pizzeria – Wilkes-Barre
- Antionio’s Pizza – West Pittston
- Apple Tree House Restaurant – Harding
- Arcaro’s the Next Generation – Pittston
- Back Road Alehouse – Swoyersville
- Baranko’s Pizza – Hazleton
- Bernie’s Pizza – Dallas
- Bettelli’s Villa – Wilkes-Barre
- Biscotto’s – Wyoming
- Brick House Pizza – Nanticoke
- Budd’s Pizza Cafe – Kingston
- Cafe Apizza – Forty Fort
- Carey’s Pub – Kingston
- Carmen’s Bakery – Hazleton
- Cebula’s Bar and Lounge – Dupont
- Chacko’s Bowling – Memory Lane Lounge – Wilkes-Barre
- Checkerboard Inn – Trucksville
- Cheers Cafe – West Pittston
- DeMuro’s Pizza – Pittston
- Dino’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant – Wilkes-Barre
- Dough Company – Wilkes-Barre
- Franco’s – Wilkes-Barre
- Fratello’s Pizzeria – Nescopeck
- Frog Pond Pub – Wilkes-Barre
- Gerry’s Pizzeria – Wilkes-Barre
- Grotto Pizza – Wilkes-Barre
- Happy Pizza – Plymouth
- Hogan’s Heros and Pizza – Dallas
- III Guys Pizza – Dallas
- Januzzi’s Pizza – Wilkes-Barre
- Joe’s Pizza – Nanticoke
- Keeley’s Alehouse – Kingston
- Kings Ristorante – Mountain Top
- La Napoli – Mountain Top
- Larry’s Pizza – Nanticoke
- Leggio’s Italian Ristorante – Plains
- Leggio’s Pizza – Dallas
- Lighthouse Inn – West Wyoming
- Lino’s Pizza – Kingston
- Lizza’s Mezzo Mezzo – Pittston
- Luca Pizza – West Pittston
- Magda’s Pizza and Deli – Wilkes-Barre
- Marty’s Pizzeria – Nanticoke
- Milan Coal Fired Pizza – Dallas
- Murphy’s Pub – Swoyersville
- Napoli’s Pizza – Pittston
- Nardone Bros – Hanover
- Nardozzo’s – Nanticoke
- Nello’s Pizza – Wilkes-Barre
- Newtown Cafe – Ashley
- Nino’s Rustic Italian Grill – Shickshinny
- Ole Tyme Charley’s – Plains
- Peppe’s Pizza – Plains
- Pizza Bella – Forty Fort
- Pizza L’Oven – Exeter
- Pizza Perfect – Trucksville
- Plains Pub – Plains
- Polock’s Pizza – Nescopeck
- Red’s Pizza and Subs – Hunlock Creek
- Revello’s Pizza – Wilkes-Barre
- Ricci’s Pizza – Wilkes-Barre
- Rodano’s – Wilkes-Barre
- Ruby’s Inn – Nanticoke
- Sabatini’s Pizza – Exeter
- Savo’s Pizza – Pittston
- Senape’s Bakery – Hazleton
- Senape’s Tavern Pitza – Hazleton
- Serpico Pizza – Wilkes-Barre
- Shady Side Tavern – Dallas
- Shandra’s Pizza – Pittston
- Shelley’s Pizza – Luzerne
- Sicilian Bella Festa – West Wyoming
- Sizzle Pi – Kingston
- Sky Zone Trampoline Park – Pittston
- Spare Time Pizza – Dallas
- TC Riley’s Pub and Inn – Wyoming
- Teberio’s Pizza and Pub – Wilkes-Barre
- Tipsy Turtle – Jenkins Township
- Togoz Pizza – Wyoming
- Tomasino’s – Dallas
- Tommy’s Pizza Corner – Kingston
- Tony’s Pizzeria – Pittston
- Town Tavern – Duryea
- Two Italian Guys Pizzeria – Hazleton
- Two Kings – Shickshinny
- Uncle Joe’s Pizza – Pittston
- Vesuvio’s – Wilkes-Barre
- Vesuvio’s Pizzeria and Sports Bar – Mountain Top
- Victory Pig Pizza – Wyoming
- Vince’s Pizza Express – Pittston
- Vito’s Bistro – Pittston
- Whatinthe Sam Hill’s Brick Oven Pizza – Wilkes-Barre
- Whistle Stop Pizza – Mountain Top
Monroe County
- Mamma Maria’s Pizza – Tobyhanna
- Nick’s Big Belly Deli – Scotrun
- Palumbo’s Pizza – East Stroudsburg
- Tony’s Restaurant and Pizza – East Stroudsburg
Montgomery County
Montour County
Northampton County
Philadelphia County
- Angelo’s Pizza – Philadelphia
- Del Rossi’s Cheesesteak & Pizza CO. – Philadelphia
- Lorenzo and Son’s Pizza – Philadelphia
- Old City Pizza – Philadelphia
- Paulie Gee’s Soul City Slice – Philadelphia
- Pizza Shackamaxon – Philadelphia
Pike County
Schuylkill County
- Basile’s Italian Delight Restaurant – Tamaqua
- Sweet Pizza Pizza – Frackville
- Vito’s Coal Fired Pizza – St Clair
Susquehanna County
- Acre Lake Store – Kingsley
- Anthony’s Restaurant and Pizzeria – Montrose
- Elegante – Forest City
- Original Italian Pizzeria Montrose – Montrose
Union County
Wayne County
- Drafts Bar and Grill – Lake Ariel
- Palermo’s Pizza – Lake Ariel
- Scarfalloto’s Towne House – Honesdale
- Two Guys From Italy – Honesdale
- Waymart Hotel – Waymart
Wyoming County
- Dandy Mini-Mart – Mehoopany
- Germana’s Pizza – Nicholson
- Pesos Pizza and Southwest Grill – Tunkhannock
- Pompei’s Pizza – Tunkhannock
- Samario’s Pizza Tunkhannock – Tunkhannock
- Snapper’s Bar & Grill – Factoryville
- The Player’s Pub – Tunkhannock
If this Pennsylvania pizza review directory helped you find a new spot to try, please share it with a fellow pizza lover, local foodie, or anyone planning a pizza road trip. I’ll keep updating this list as I review more pizzerias, so drop a comment with your favorite pizza place, tell me which county I should visit next, or let me know if there’s a hidden gem that deserves a full NEPA Pizza Review.
Leave a Comment