Shady Side Tavern Dallas

Shady Side Tavern Pan Fried Sicilian Pizza Stands Out From the Rest

If you’re looking for the good Pan Fried Sicilian Pizza in Dallas, PA, Shady Side Tavern is a must-visit. Located at 3600 PA-309, Dallas, PA 18612, Shady Side Tavern is a local favorite, known for its Pan Fried Sicilian Pizza (PFS), Old Forge pizza, chicken wings, and a variety of appetizers. It’s also a great bar for watching sports with friends.

Highly Recommended Golden Brown Crispy Crust

After hearing multiple recommendations from my readers, I decided to try Shady Side Tavern’s Pan Fried Sicilian Pizza for myself, and I’m glad I did. I ordered a PFS with onions to go, and it met my expectations. Unlike most pan-fried Sicilian pizzas in the Back Mountain area, this one was baked to a deeper, well done, golden-brown perfection. The crust was a standout — crispy on the bottom, crunchy around the edges, yet soft on the inside, creating a delightful texture contrast in every bite.

Want to know what the best pizza sauce is? I tested, ranked, and scored them all! Here are my Pizza Sauce Rankings!

Super Saucy Fresh Tasting Tomatoes

The sauce was another highlight, generously applied, vibrant, and chunky with a natural tomato flavor. It had a very light seasoning, if any, with fresh sliced and diced onions adding a nice touch. The cheese was particularly unique; it had a thick, matte finish and sometimes slid off in one piece. It seemed to be a blend of cheddar and another gooey cheese, but the exact combination was intriguingly hard to pinpoint.

For those curious about the grease factor, Shady Side Tavern’s Pan Fried Sicilian Pizza leans towards the moderately high side. It’s deliciously flavorful but definitely on the greasier side of things.

What Makes Shady Side Tavern Dallas Stand Out

Overall, Shady Side Tavern offers a Pan Fried Sicilian Pizza that stands out due to its perfectly baked crust, generous sauce, and distinctive cheese blend. The crust was my favorite part, with the sauce being a close second. If you’re in Dallas, PA, and craving a truly unique and well-crafted Pan Fried Sicilian Pizza, Shady Side Tavern is the place to go.