F Italian Pizza 2 on Main Avenue: A Hustling Neighborhood Spot With a Grandma Slice That Hits Hardest

I ordered through the Slice app, paid the bill, and reviewed the pizza like every other customer. No heads-up. No comps.

A number of locals who live around Main Avenue kept telling me the same thing: F Italian Pizza 2 has a good, solid New York style pizza, a taco pizza, and a grandma pizza worth trying. So I stopped in for the first time and tried a slice of each. Then their Sicilian caught my eye, thick with a beautiful-looking crust and just piled with cheese, so that came along too.

Walk Outside to Walk Back Inside

The setup here is unique. One side is a small takeout-only shop. The dining area is on the other side, so you exit the premises and walk around to get your table service. You walk outside to walk back inside, which is pretty cool. There are also a couple of picnic tables out on the sidewalk if you want to eat there.

As soon as you open the door to the takeout side, there’s just a little bit of room, but there’s a nice slice case with garlic knots, a couple of gourmet pizzas, strombolis, and more. Lots going on. That’s where I spotted the grandma pizza I needed to try.

Parking is a little interesting, so it’s worth knowing before you go. There’s a little alley between the buildings you can park in, a paved area out front, and of course street parking. It’s not all that challenging to get a spot. It’s just a unique situation.

A Hustling Owner Who Drives in From New Jersey Every Day

The customer service is great. The super friendly guy working the front was the owner, and man, he was hustling, greeting everybody.

Here’s a tidbit I learned: the owner travels from New Jersey every single day to open up the shop and work all day before heading back home. He is putting in the work, and he’s serving a really good product.

Pizza With Scranton’s Finest

One cool interaction: some of the Scranton Police Department’s finest walked in, and we got to have a great conversation about the pizza and the food. Their top recommendation was the chicken cutlets and the chicken parm entrée. They’re also the reason I knew about the dining room. I wouldn’t have known you could dine in if they hadn’t told me.

There was a lot of foot traffic on the sidewalk where I was reviewing the pizza, too. Several people asked what I thought, a couple of onlookers stopped by, and everybody who walked past said, “We’re glad you’re here. This place has really good pizza and great food.” It’s always cool to have moments like that on a pizza review.

The NY Style: A Sandpaper-Crisp Bottom and a Satisfying Chew

I got a 14-inch New York style pizza, and the crust was my favorite part. It had a really nice rough texture on the bottom, almost like sandpaper. Very crisp underneath, but the interior had a super satisfying dense chew. Light, but still with some density to it.

The sauce was more savory, with Italian seasoning leading the way. Just a really nice sauce. The cheese was presumably mozzarella, with some nice caramelization spots on top.

Overall, it’s in the party pleaser category. A solid pizza that everybody is bound to enjoy. Take it to a party, and pretty much everyone would find something they like about it.

The Taco Pizza: Light, Fresh, and Almost Refreshing

I got a 10-inch personal taco pizza, and man, that thing was light, fresh, and vibrant. The ground beef had a little bit of a kick to it. I wouldn’t call it spicy, but it was there. It was topped with fresh lettuce, finely diced tomatoes, and good seasoning.

Basically, it’s a taco on a pizza crust. Swap out the tortilla for the crust, but in a well-executed version. I always like when the lettuce is still crisp because they dress it on top afterward. It was almost a refreshing slice. Definitely try it.

The Sicilian: A Crust That Steals the Show

The Sicilian was a pretty standard square crust, but the bottom and edge had such a great color and texture. Some micro blisters on the dough gave it a really nice texture. They definitely hit different on your tongue and palate.

It was piled with cheese. Tons of cheese, if you’re a cheese lover. For me, I’d redistribute the proportions a little, with a bit more sauce and a little less cheese. But I know NEPA loves its cheese, and for a lot of folks this will be a classic. Either way, the crust was the star of the show.

The Grandma Slice: Very Good, Bordering on Great

My favorite by far was the grandma pizza. Basically a thin Sicilian crust: very thin, very crispy, bordering on crunchy.

It had a chunky tomato sauce that was vibrant, with a fresh, fruity taste. Savory and lightly seasoned. Sliced fresh mozzarella on top, with some fresh basil in there. It was light, easy to enjoy, and had plenty of flavor and lots of character. That one hit hardest. A very good grandma slice, bordering on great. I a little more sauce on this pizza would have put it over the top!

Pizzaiolo’s Notes 🍕

  • 🍞 The crust is the signature across the board. Sandpaper-crisp on the NY style, micro blisters on the Sicilian, and crunchy-thin on the grandma.
  • 🍅 The grandma’s chunky, fruity, lightly seasoned sauce is the best sauce in the building.
  • 🌮 Dressing the taco pizza after the bake keeps the lettuce crisp and the slice light and fresh.
  • 🧀 Sicilian lovers who want maximum cheese will be happy. I’d nudge it toward a little more sauce.
  • 🚓 When Scranton PD recommends the chicken parm, you listen.

What I’d Order Next Time

  • The chicken parm, on the Scranton PD’s recommendation
  • The buttery garlic knots I spotted in the slice case

How Far Would I Drive for This Pizza?

I’d drive about 15 minutes for this pizza. Essentially, if I’m in town, I’m stopping in, and that grandma slice is the first thing I’m grabbing.

Final Thoughts on F Italian Pizza 2

All of the slices were at least good, and the grandma was very good, bordering on great. Add an owner who drives in from New Jersey every day, a neighborhood that’s glad to have him, and a crust that’s the signature on everything, and you’ve got a really good neighborhood spot on Main Avenue.

Have You Been to F Italian Pizza 2?

👉 Which slice is your go-to? 👉 Have you tried the chicken parm yet?

Drop it in the comments. Let’s talk pizza 🍕

Pizza is Similar to:

Scores

I scored these pizzas 24 hours after my visit.

Grandma Pizza

  • Pizza Ordered: Grandma Pizza Slice
  • Style: Grandma
  • Visit: November 2026
CategoryScore
Crust7.9
Sauce7.7
Cheese7.6
Taste7.8
Crispy/Cooked7.9
Value7.0
Overall7.8

Taco Pizza

  • Pizza Ordered: 10″ Personal Taco Pizza
  • Style: New York Style Taco Pizza
  • Visit: November 2026
CategoryScore
Crust7.7
Saucen/a
Cheese7.4
Taste7.7
Crispy/Cooked7.7
Value7.0
Overall7.5

New York Style Pizza

  • Pizza Ordered: 14″ New York Style Pizza
  • Style: New York Style Round
  • Visit: November 2026
CategoryScore
Crust7.7
Sauce7.4
Cheese7.4
Taste7.5
Crispy/Cooked7.6
Value6.9
Overall7.4

Sicilian Pizza

  • Pizza Ordered: Sicilian Pizza Slice
  • Style: Sicilian Square
  • Visit: November 2026
CategoryScore
Crust7.5
Sauce7.4
Cheese7.1
Taste7.1
Crispy/Cooked7.5
Value7.0
Overall7.2

The story behind the scores: The grandma slice leads the way at 7.8 Overall, with the top Crust and Crispy/Cooked marks of the day at 7.9, plus a 7.7 for that chunky, fruity, vibrant sauce. The taco pizza came in second at 7.5, its 7.7 for Taste earned by a light, fresh, almost refreshing slice. The NY style landed at 7.4, with a 7.7 Crust for that sandpaper-crisp bottom and satisfying chew, a true party pleaser. The Sicilian scored a 7.2, its 7.5 Crust and Crispy/Cooked showing off that beautiful color and micro blisters, with the cheese-heavy proportions holding the Cheese and Taste at 7.1. Across all four, the crust was the signature, and every slice was at least good.


F Italian Pizza 2
1000 S Main Avenue, Scranton, PA 18504
Lackawanna County
NY Style · Grandma · Sicilian · Specialty Pizzas · Chicken Parm · Takeout and Dine-In · Sidewalk Picnic Tables


Talk Pizza With Me on Social Media!

Support my work by starting your Amazon shopping trip using THIS LINK! It costs you nothing, but helps NEPA Pizza Review support small businesses and purchase pizza supplies and equipment to keep creating free content for you!