Large Pizza for Under $10?! Tony’s Restaurant and Pizzeria Delivers a Rock-Solid NY Slice in East Stroudsburg
If you told me in 2026 that I could walk into a pizzeria and grab a large New York-style pizza for $9.95, I’d probably assume there was a catch.
At Tony’s Pizzeria and Restaurant… there isn’t.
And that’s what makes this one so interesting.
The Setting: Old School Charm on Crystal Street
Tony’s sits right on Crystal Street in East Stroudsburg, and if you know the area, you know this block has some serious character. A row of restaurants, bars, and even a brewery all packed into one stretch with plenty of charm and easy meter parking — it’s the kind of place you can make a full night out of.
Step inside Tony’s and you immediately get hit with that nostalgic neighborhood pizzeria vibe. Stickers covering the door, pizza artwork on the walls — nothing overdone, just authentic and lived-in. The kind of place that feels like it’s been part of the community forever.
The Deal That Pulls You In
Let’s get right to it:
👉 $9.95 for a LARGE cheese pizza every Monday
That’s the hook… and it’s a strong one.
I stopped in around 4:00 PM and there were already multiple tables filled with people working on full pies. Within the 10 minutes I waited for my pizza, a line started forming behind me.
You could tell right away — this is an after-school hotspot.
And honestly, I love seeing that. Pizza still doing what it’s always done best… bringing people together.
Quick side note — since I’m sticking to my FitAF routine and only doing a slice or two, I passed the rest of my pizza over to a group of students hanging out inside so they could use their money on apps instead. Super polite kids. Cool moment, and exactly what a neighborhood pizza spot should feel like.
The Pizza: Exactly What You Want in NY Style
Now let’s talk about the most important part — the pizza itself.
Because a deal like this only works if the pizza delivers.
And this one absolutely does.
This is a rock-solid, quintessential New York-style pie.
The crust is stretched thin and even, baked to a beautiful golden brown. It’s fully foldable, with just enough crisp on the bottom to give you that initial bite, followed by a nice chew and tenderness throughout.
What stood out most to me here was the proportions.
• Crust thickness — just right
• Sauce — slightly heavier than most local spots (not overloaded, just… perfect)
• Cheese — generous without crossing the line into too much
That balance is everything in a NY-style pizza, and Tony’s nails it.
The sauce leans mild and neutral, which makes this a really easy pizza to enjoy for a wide range of people. I did spot a can of Cento tomatoes on the counter, so I’d guess that’s part of the equation here.
The cheese has a clean melt, solid stretch, and mild flavor that complements the sauce instead of overpowering it.
If you’re someone who likes to customize your slice, this is one I’d probably hit with a little oregano and parmesan. Totally not necessary — but it would take it exactly where I like it.
The Verdict: A True Party Pleaser
This is what I call a party pleaser pizza.
It’s not trying to reinvent the wheel. It’s not chasing trends. It’s just doing classic New York-style pizza the right way — and doing it at a price that almost doesn’t make sense anymore.
From kids… to casual pizza fans… to full-on pizza snobs…
This is a pie that everyone can enjoy.
And when you combine that with a $9.95 price point?
You’ve got one of the best pizza deals in the East Stroudsburg / Stroudsburg area right now.
Want to know what the best pizza sauce is? I tested, ranked, and scored them all! Here are my Pizza Sauce Rankings!
Final Thoughts
Tony’s Restaurant and Pizzeria proves that you don’t need gimmicks to win people over.
Just:
• A great location
• A welcoming, nostalgic vibe
• A strong community presence
• And a rock-solid NY-style pizza at an unbeatable price
If you’re searching for:
- Best pizza in East Stroudsburg
- Top pizza deals near Stroudsburg
- Affordable NY-style pizza in the Poconos
This one deserves a spot on your list.
💬 Have you tried Tony’s Monday deal? Is this the best pizza deal in the area right now?
NEPA Pizza Review Verdict:
A throwback-style deal paired with a dependable, well-executed New York pie. Simple, balanced, and built to please.
Rating the Pizza
- Restaurant: Tony’s Pizza East Stroudsburg
- Address: Crystal St, East Stroudsburg, PA 18301
- Dine In/Take Out: Dine In
- Pizza Ordered: Large New York Style Pizza
- Date: April 2026
| Rating Category | Rating Score |
|---|---|
| Crust | 7.8 |
| Sauce | 7.4 |
| Cheese | 7.7 |
| Taste | 7.6 |
| Crispy/Cooked Properly | 7.9 |
| Value | 8.8 |
| Overall Rating | 7.7 |
Pizza is Similar to: Palumbo’s
Talk Pizza With Me on Social Media!
Support my work by starting your Amazon shipping trip using THIS LINK! It costs you nothing, but helps NEPA Pizza Review support small businesses and purchase pizza supplies and equipment to keep creating free content for you!
Leave a Comment