Pat's Pizza and Hoagies - Carbondale

The Ultimate Guide to Pat’s Pizza and Hoagies in Carbondale: A Flavorful Journey Through Sicilian Pizza, Stromboli, and More

Pat’s Pizza and Hoagies – A Local Favorite

Nestled at 21 Hospital St, Carbondale, PA 18407, Pat’s Pizza and Hoagies is a beloved local gem known for its wide range of offerings, including pizza, hoagies, salads, and appetizers. Whether you’re picking up dinner for the family or catering a party, this small takeout spot has become a go-to destination for those seeking hearty, flavorful food that satisfies every craving. From their signature Sicilian pizza to their generously packed strombolis, Pat’s consistently delivers quality and value.

2025 Review: A Gourmet Adventure with 4-Cheese Pizza and Stromboli

In my most recent visit to Pat’s Pizza and Hoagies in Carbondale, I explored two standout menu items: the 4-Cheese Square Pizza with Pepperoni and Onions and the Cheesesteak Stromboli with Mushrooms. Here’s my take on these crowd-pleasers:

4-Cheese Square Pizza

Pat’s 4-Cheese Square Pizza is a revelation for pizza lovers. Crafted on a thinner crust resembling a grandma-style base, it is dense, soft, chewy, and baked to a perfect golden brown. The sauce used for this pizza differs from their traditional pizza sauce, delivering a punchy, oregano-forward flavor. It’s layered with mozzarella, American, provolone, and grated cheese, complemented by the savory additions of fried onions and pepperoni. Together, these elements create a flavor-packed bite that’s truly unforgettable. It’s a must-try for anyone looking to elevate their pizza game in Carbondale.

Cheesesteak Stromboli

If indulgence is what you’re after, the Cheesesteak Stromboli is a top contender. This 4+ pound masterpiece is loaded with seasoned steak, gooey cheese, and earthy mushrooms, all wrapped in a thin, golden-brown crust. The dough is perfectly baked with no raw spots, ensuring a satisfying crunch with every bite. Generous portions of steak and cheese make this stromboli perfect for sharing, but it’s so good you might not want to.

2019 Review: Sicilian and Round Pizzas at a Party

Back in 2019, I first encountered Pat’s Pizza and Hoagies during a friend’s diaper party. Although the pizzas had been sitting out for about 90 minutes before I got to them, their quality still shone through—a testament to Pat’s ability to craft pizzas that stand the test of time.

Round Pizzas

We tried two large round pizzas: one plain and one topped with sausage. The crust was thick, dense, and chewy, with a golden-brown finish that showed off its experienced preparation. The toppings were generous, with the sausage adding a spicy, flavorful kick. The sauce was hearty and savory, applied in just the right amount to keep the pizza moist and flavorful.

Sicilian Pizza

The Sicilian pizza was the star of the show, featuring a thick, fluffy crust baked in a pan with a touch of oil for a crispy, flavorful bottom. Topped with pepperoni, the Sicilian slice offered a satisfying contrast between the crunchy base, savory sauce, and gooey mozzarella. Even after sitting out, this pizza retained its integrity and flavor, proving its worth as a party favorite.

Why Pat’s Pizza and Hoagies Should Be Your Go-To for Gatherings

Pat’s Pizza in Carbondale offers more than just great flavor—it provides exceptional value and convenience. Their pizzas and strombolis are perfect for gatherings, thanks to their generous portions, long shelf life, and ability to stay delicious even after sitting out. With topping prices as low as $1.50 and a recipe designed to please everyone, it’s no wonder Pat’s is a local staple.

Final Thoughts: Add Pat’s to Your Pizza Bucket List

Whether you’re indulging in their 4-Cheese Square Pizza, savoring a Cheesesteak Stromboli, or enjoying their Sicilian pizza at a party, Pat’s Pizza and Hoagies in Carbondale consistently delivers on taste, quality, and value. If you’re in the area and searching for “pizza near Carbondale,” look no further than Pat’s. Have you tried Pat’s Pizza and Hoagies? Share your experience in the comments below!