What Is the Best Way to Cook a Nardone Bros Pizza?

Nardone Bros has been making pizza since 1942 and many in NEPA and beyond grew up with their cold boxed pizza from the grocery store!

NEPA Grew Up On Nardone Bros, but We All Cooked It Very Differently!

Like many in Northeast PA, I grew up on Nardone Bros Pizza Hanover, which is a cold, boxed pizza you buy from the refrigerated section in the grocery store. It’s something of an Old Forge style pizza featuring a spongy crust garlic flavored sauce, and American Cheese. People cook it so many different ways, and there is much debate about what is the best method of heating it up! Check out the video for all of my findings in this throwback to my childhood!
 
Check out the video below where I test 6 of the most popular ways to cook and eat Nardone Bros Pizza. You’ll be surprised what the best method is!
 
Cooking on the Grill!

Ways to Cook Nardone’s Pizza According to Locals:

Be sure to let everyone know your choice in the poll below!
  • Eat it Cold
  • Eat it at Room Temperature
  • Eat it Stale (Leave out on counter for 3 days)
  • Grill it
  • Grill it (in cast iron skillet)
  • Bake it (on baking stone/steel)
  • Bake it (on foil)
  • Fry it in Frying Pan/Skillet (Dry)
  • Fry it in Frying Pan/Skillet (in Oil/Butter)
  • Deep Fry it
  • Microwave it
  • Cook in Toaster Oven
  • Cook in Air Fryer
  • Boil it
  • Sous Vide
  • Toast in Toaster
  • Cook in Waffle Maker
  • Broil under broiler
  • Iron
  • Hair Dryer
  • Cook on Blackstone Griddle
  • Bake in Pizza Oven
  • Smoke it (in Smoker)
  • Cook Over Campfire

Best Toppings or Additions to Nardone Bros Pizza According to Locals:

  • Oregano
  • Garlic Powder
  • Pepperoni
  • Mayo (on crust)
 
The Ratings
 
Restaurant: Nardone Bros Pizza
Location: 420 New Commerce Blvd, Hanover, PA 18706
Date: April 2021
Eat In/Take Out: Take Out (From Grocery Store)
 
Pizza Ordered: Box of Pizza
Price: $5.99
Crust: 5.9
Sauce: 6.3
Cheese: 6.2
Overall Taste: 6.4
Crispy/Cooked Properly: 5.9
Overall Value: 9.0
OVERALL RATING: 6.2
Similar to: Proferra’s Pizza, Longo’s Pizza, Dee Jay’s Pizza

Talk Pizza With Me on Social Media!